Carriers American Modern Insurance Group Customer Service: 800-543-2644 Claims: 800-375-2075 American Strategic Insurance Customer Service: 866-274-8765 Claims: 866-274-8765 Auto Owners Insurance Customer Service: 517-323-1200 Claims: 888-252-4626 Chubb Group Customer Service: 800-248-2275 Claims: 800-252-4670 Dairyland Auto Customer Service: 800-334-0090 Claims: 800-334-0090 Fireman's Fund Customer Service: 866-386-3932 Claims: 866-386-3932 Foremost Insurance Group Customer Service: 800-527-3905 Claims: 800-527-3907 GMAC Insurance Customer Service: 877-325-7727 Claims: 800-325-1088 Grange Insurance Group Customer Service: 800-414-5550 Claims: 800-546-8850 Infinity Customer Service: 800-782-1020 Claims: 800-334-1661 Kemper Preferred Customer Service: 877-252-7878 Claims: 888-252-2799 Mendota Insurance Customer Service: 800-422-0792 Claims: 800-422-0793 Metlife Customer Service: 800-422-4272 Claims: 800-854-6011 Pacific Specialty Customer Service: 800-303-5000 Claims: 800-962-1172 Progressive Customer Service: 800-925-2886 Claims: 800-925-2886 Safeco Insurance Customer Service: 800-332-3226 Claims: 888-557-5010 Secura Insurance Customer Service: 800-558-3405 Claims: 800-868-2869 State Auto Insurance Customer Service: 800-444-9950 Claims: 800-766-1850 Titan Customer Service: 800-888-8424 Claims: 800-926-3168 Travelers Customer Service: 866-933-7287 Claims: 800-252-4633 Unitrin Specialty Customer Service: 800-218-8553 Claims: 888-253-7834